Now accepting Telehealth appointments. Schedule a virtual visit.
Skip to main content

Lumpectomy or Mastectomy: Which Is Best for Your Condition?

Lumpectomy or Mastectomy: Which Is Best for Your Condition?

Are you dealing with a breast cancer diagnosis? It’s normal to wonder which breast surgery is best for your needs. Both lumpectomy and mastectomy aim to remove cancerous tissue, but there are a few key differences between the two.

Elvira Klause, MD, FACS, specializes in oncology procedures in Laguna Hills, California, and our team is here to help you make an informed treatment decision. 

Here’s what you need to know about the differences between lumpectomy and mastectomy and how to decide which approach is best for your condition.

Lumpectomy vs. mastectomy

Lumpectomy and mastectomy are two of the most common breast cancer surgeries, and it’s important to understand how each method works.


Lumpectomy involves removing the cancerous tumor along with a small, surrounding margin of healthy tissue. Since it’s a smaller surgical intervention compared to mastectomy, lumpectomy is often called breast-conserving surgery.

Lumpectomy may be the best option for you if you have early-stage breast cancer. Dr. Klause considers factors like tumor size, location, and your overall breast size to determine if you’re a good candidate. 

If you get a lumpectomy, Dr. Klause often recommends radiation therapy after surgery to destroy any remaining cancer cells.


Mastectomy involves removing all of your breast tissue. Depending on your situation, breast reconstruction surgery might be an option along with mastectomy to restore the appearance of your breast.

Dr. Klause may recommend mastectomy if you have a large cancerous tumor, multiple tumors, or a high genetic risk of breast cancer. Since mastectomy removes all breast tissue, it provides a more definitive approach to eliminate cancer.

Which breast surgery technique is right for you?

Breast cancer surgery is a major procedure, and Dr. Klause considers all of the most important factors to help you determine which option is best for you.

She starts by reviewing your medical history and your diagnosis, weighing factors like the stage of cancer, tumor size, tumor location, and any breast cancer-related genetic mutations you have. She talks with you about your personal preferences in an open and detailed discussion.

As you make your decision, we can provide you with detailed information about the benefits, risks, and potential outcomes associated with each approach. 

Lumpectomy is a simpler surgical procedure, but it’s often followed by radiation treatment. Mastectomy, on the other hand, is more complex, but offers more comprehensive cancer removal.

If you’re considering mastectomy, take breast reconstruction into account, too. Breast reconstruction can restore the shape, size, and appearance of your breast after mastectomy.

The choice between lumpectomy and mastectomy is significant, and you don’t have to navigate the decision alone. We consider your specific situation, and we’re here to empower you to make the choice that‘s best for you.

Schedule your breast surgery consultation with Dr. Klause online or call our Laguna Hills, California, office at 949-245-6910 to get started.

You Might Also Enjoy...

Tips to Help You Recover Quickly After Hernia Surgery

Are you scheduled for hernia surgery? It’s a safe, effective way to treat hernias, but it’s normal to wonder what to expect after the procedure. Get our best tips for a quick, successful recovery from hernia surgery here.

Home Remedies for Hemorrhoids

Do you have hemorrhoids? You don’t have to live with the discomfort. Learn about tried-and-true home remedies for hemorrhoids here, and find out when to make a doctor’s appointment for professional hemorrhoid care.

4 Benefits of Laparoscopic Surgery

Do you need surgery? It’s normal to have questions about which surgical technique is right for you. Learn more about laparoscopic surgery and find out why it’s the gold standard for many of the most common procedures.

How Does Chemotherapy Work?

Are you starting cancer treatment? It’s normal to have questions. Learn more about chemotherapy, how it works, and how it supports surgical oncology for a more thorough approach to cancer treatment.

I Need a Surgical Breast Biopsy: What Can I Expect?

A surgical breast biopsy is one of the best ways to detect breast cancer, especially if other tests are inconclusive. And if you’re scheduled for a surgical biopsy, it’s normal to have questions. Find out what to expect here.

When Do Hemorrhoids Require Medical Intervention?

You’ve tried topical creams, sitz baths, and other remedies, but you still have painful hemorrhoids. These treatments are effective for some people, but they don’t work for everyone. Find out if it’s time to see a doctor about your symptoms.